Heads up, if you want to get someone The Dignity of Dependence for Christmas, it’s half off when you order directly from Notre Dame University Press until Dec 1 with “26GIVEBKS.” (And you can preorder the new, LARGE PRINT edition for your mom or anyone with visual challenges in your life).
Is a book called Kobuk the Destroyer an Other Feminisms book at heart?
The book is a history of product testing, and I really enjoyed it. (If you like reading about the creation of a standard pseudo-bird to be shot into jet engines to simulate bird strikes, this is for you).
It covers some Other Feminisms-related topics about crash test dummies that are also covered in Caroline Criado Perez’s excellent Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men. It also has a lot more details than Invisible Women about the uses of unembalmed corpses to test cars for crash safety.
But the part I want to highlight is about how designers of prescription pill bottles balance the needs of two vulnerable, “not normal” populations: the young and the old.
The Palm N Turn bottle lid kept kids out of pill bottles while still allowing most adults to access their medications. And it made a huge difference to safety:
In a trial period in Ontario, the bottle cap generated a 91 percent drop in child poisonings. It was quickly mandated not only across Canada but in the United States as well. Between 1972 and 2022, unintentional poisonings of children dropped by 80 percent.
I loved reading about how manufacturers set the standard for how difficult the bottle can be, and how they get real kids to stress test their prototypes:
Modern testing for child-resistant containers mirrors Breault’s efforts. Various private firms run these tests, following detailed protocols laid out by the CPSC. Before any new kid-blocking device can hit the market, it must face a panel of fifty three- and four-year-olds. In pairs, the kids are sat down in a well-lit, distraction-free room, where the test supervisor asks each to open a test container with a placebo inside. If neither child has succeeded after 5 minutes, the supervisor opens the container in front of them, closes it, and gives them another 5 minutes.
They also tell the kids they can use their teeth if they like, in case the youth are holding back on one of their most powerful tools.
Once they’ve verified they can keep kids out, they have to double check that elderly adults can still get in. After all, if it’s too hard to open, an adult is likely to just leave the cap off.
After it passes the kids’ test, the container goes to a panel of one hundred adults between fifty and seventy years old, 90 percent of whom must be able to open and properly close it again within 5 minutes.
I particularly appreciate the way the product testers test with two kids who can collaborate. What’s safe for one kid working in isolation may not be safe for siblings.
The other passage that felt particularly Other Feminisms-adjacent had to do with who gets blamed when a certain subset of people don’t fit your newly standardized product or process.
At the time, workers in places like steel mills and mines were being injured and killed at alarming rates. One survey found that between July 1906 and June 1907, a startling 526 workers died on the job in Pennsylvania’s Allegheny County. In 1912, about 20,000 Americans died from workplace-related injuries.
In response, some psychologists convinced themselves that the industrial workers who were being injured were victims of a newly diagnosed affliction they called “accident proneness.” As chronicled by historian John C. Burnham in Accident Prone: A History of Technology, Psychology, and Misfits of the Machine Age, this movement identified the clumsy and unlucky as sharing a deviant sort of personality trait, not so different from pedophilia or pyromania.
Psychologists worked to develop tests to pick out those afflicted—agreed-upon indicators included poor eyesight and left-handedness—so they could be kept away from machinery. (This “intellectual” effort raised the classic question of whether the accident-prone were born that way or products of their environment.
In 1935, one Times columnist fretted over a possible pride movement: “They will found clubs; and to be accident-prone will be to despise the normally capable as the professed plain man despises the intellectual.”
It’s wild that the designers could accurately notice that physical factors like eyesight and left-handedness correlated with higher risk of injury and then concluded, well:
A major theme of The Dignity of Dependence is the many ways our built and social “defaults” treat women as defective men.
Women are embarrassingly and abberationally pregnancy-prone in the way that left-handers are accident prone.
Good design looks more like the pill bottle tops. It acknowledges conflicting needs (and that one design may not include everyone perfectly) but it builds design around finding the best tradeoff possible. And it doesn’t dismiss little kids as “poisoning-prone” or rely on the parents to fill the safety gap caused by bad design.




A lot of architectural designs are moving toward universal design, where the main way people interact with the space is accessible, instead of the accessible option being secondary. Some of our public clients are really embracing this attitude, which is encouraging!
I have yet to see a daily pill minder (a container with separate compartments for each day of the week) that is childproof in any meaningful way.