Other Feminisms

Share this post

Taking the Measure of Men

www.otherfeminisms.com

Discover more from Other Feminisms

Creating a culture that values interdependence over autonomy
Over 3,000 subscribers
Continue reading
Sign in

Taking the Measure of Men

How men describe their own masculinity

Leah Libresco Sargeant
Apr 25, 2022
9
Share this post

Taking the Measure of Men

www.otherfeminisms.com
53
Share

This week, I’m turning the focus to men and masculinity. On Thursday, I’ll share highlights from your thoughts on when we rely on writing rules as a substitute for inculcating virtue.

three man sitting on gray surface
Photo by Toa Heftiba on Unsplash

The New York Times has been doing a series of focus groups with Americans on various topics (younger women on work, teenagers on their future, etc) and the most recent was a group of conservative-leaning men.

Here’s the section that seemed particularly of interest:

Patrick Healy: I want to ask each of you to throw out a word or two on this: What does it mean to be a man?

Robert: Provide for your family.

Michael: Compassion.

Tony: Being responsible and being a model for your kids.

Joe: I think providing for your family, teaching your children right from wrong, leading by example.

Derrick: Having integrity.

Krupal: Taking care of your family and being respectful to others, regardless of your personal perspective.

Robert: From my religion’s standpoint, the man is in charge. The responsibility falls upon a man in certain areas. And if something fails, it’s the man’s responsibility on why it failed, not the woman’s.

The men in the focus group put their emphasis on male duties not male privileges.

Share

The duties can still spark conflict or leave women feeling sidelined. A husband who feels like he has the final responsibility may be reluctant to agree with his wife that she will take the lead on a family project.

But still, amid all the discussion of toxic masculinity, I appreciated that these men began with thoughts about what they owe others, not what they were entitled to receive.

Twitter avatar for @SerenaSigillito
Serena Sigillito @SerenaSigillito
There's a lot of great writing on sexuality and gender from women who separate the wheat from the chaff in feminist scholarship, traditional gender roles for women, etc. But is there anyone doing something similar for men? Who's writing about healthy, virtuous masculinity?
4:00 PM ∙ Dec 2, 2021
27Likes2Retweets

Some time ago, Serena Sigillito put out a call for good writers on masculinity, and I’d like to echo her here.

What, if anything, do you see as distinctly masculine (and positive!)?

Where do you find fruitful reading on masculinity?

Leave a comment

9
Share this post

Taking the Measure of Men

www.otherfeminisms.com
53
Share
Previous
Next
53 Comments
Share this discussion

Taking the Measure of Men

www.otherfeminisms.com
Jen Roth
Apr 25, 2022Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant

I generally think of virtues as virtues, and not tied to one gender or another. I realize that many men have been raised to think of particular virtues as specifically manly and that it can cause an identity crisis when they no longer are, but I'm not sure what to do about that. I think dividing virtues and traits into "masculine" and "feminine" constrain people from understanding the whole of who they are and really developing their full potential as people—not just in some kind of fuzzy self-actualization way but in terms of how best they can contribute to their families and communities and the world.

That said, I think one specifically masculine virtue is to be conscious of one's physical strength and what one can do with it, for good and for ill, and to use it for good. (Yes, not all men are physically strong and a lot of women are, but this is one area where there really is a significant natural difference on the whole.) Similarly, it's a virtue to realize that pregnancy and childbearing take a toll on women in a way they don't on men, and do what one can to relieve that toll.

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
3 replies
Ivan
Apr 25, 2022Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant

Phil Christman is, of course, essential on this (and the entirety of his recent book, which includes this essay, is self-recommending): https://hedgehogreview.com/issues/identitieswhat-are-they-good-for/articles/what-is-it-like-to-be-a-man

Expand full comment
Reply
Share
7 replies
51 more comments...
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Leah Libresco Sargeant
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing