For the buttons, what about a simpler version of the same sentiment? For instance, "equality is not interchangeability" or even "equality ≠ interchangeability" instead of the full sentence?
This is the comment I signed in to make. The "premised on" construction is way too much syntax for a small sticker. Equality ≠ Interchangeability would be perfect.
I probably wouldn't use the ≠ symbol in this. First, because too many people don't know what it means; and second, because it's a math symbol, in which context equality actually is interchangeability.
-on the yellow one, I recommend changing the font to something other than Impact. It’s a little overused. If you want something super easy to access but less overused you could try Helvetica or Gotham? Both of those are also used very often but idk what you have access to. Canva has a lot of good options as well! Try to go for something that isn’t known as a “display” font.
-on the purple/blue one, I recommend reducing the amount of space between the two lines of text (this is called “leading”), it’s a little too wide. I also recommend changing the colors to something less saturated; the current colors might not print well. Maybe a dustier or darker blue?
I like other people’s comments about shortening the phrases too. And I like the hand clip art. I love that you didn’t use AI!
"treat the patient’s pain as legitimate even if it didn’t have a clear-cut “answer” and formulate a treatment plan that would address the patient’s concerns while also being clear that they couldn’t promise a definitive solution. Doctors need to work a lot harder on developing these kinds of skills."
LOLOLOLOL understatement. Insurance billing incentivizes doctors to choose specificity over prudent hesitation. There is no billing code for "no definitive solution" that won't get you audited if you use it "too ofte" somehow. And even with nuanced training, doctors get the nuance beaten out of them by the medical system. Perverse incentives eventually result in doctors considering certain types of pain illegitimate, not because the pain isn't real but because the pain isn't provable or categorizable. Sigh
Just hear to say I love the non-pink options :) I have a "women/feminism" section of my bookshelf and I'm so annoyed at how pink it is. It isn't just your book. (I griped about this to my husband once and he pointed out that his copy of St. Ignatius's Spiritual Exercises, a 1970s printing, is the same color, ha)
OK first I need to make a correction: here, not hear. With my background this is embarrassing for me, so, there's that.
Second, I'm really intrigued by this pink-as-female-coding thing. Of all stereotypes, this is the most superficial one.
If you have young children, see if your library has "The blue pickup" by Monica mikai and I can't remember the illustrator. It's a neat story about a girl who helps her granddad fix cars in Jamaica. I liked it enough to add to our home library. But it does have subtle "girl power" vibes which I keep thinking about. It's atypical but not subversive really for a girl to help fix cars. But there are hot pink flowers decorating every page, and in the end Granddad gives her a socket wrench set in a pink box. I don't really have any commentary here, it's just a thing I keep thinking about.
But yeah, it's pretty silly--some of us flip out if a young boy chooses pink as his favorite color, too. So superficial! There are much more important things to worry about!
I like the women's equality not being interchangeable button.
As for the "untethered self" one, I wondered what was the real message? Two clasped hands, one appearing to be feminine, the other masculine. It seems to be celebrating the two as husband and wife clasped together and tethered.
It's a wonderful ideal, but what is it saying to those who haven't yet married, or who have lost their spouses through death? Are they being told that they are untethered and thus unreal?
Thanks for explaining, but even then, the message of being untethered could be linked with a different type of image if the goal is to encourage living in community with others. Perhaps a group of people together?
"What does 'slightly conversion disorder-y problems' mean?"
Since, in rare cases, purely psychological problems can produce dramatic physical effects (as in conversion disorder), it's therefore commonly speculated that, much more commonly, psychological problems outright cause, or at least needlessly worsen, patients' physical problems, especially the vaguer-seeming, tough-to-explain ones.
Especially when patients testify to a physical complaint that hasn't been verified by independent physical testing (sometimes because it can't affordably be verified this way; other times, it could be, but nobody has thought to try yet), clinicians may interpret the patient's testimony as evidence of a mainly, or at least significantly, psychological problem. (BD McClay describes how this works here: https://www.thedriftmag.com/the-bad-patient/ )
Maybe the patient is somatizing psychological distress, or has health anxiety blowing fairly minor ailments and discomforts all out of proportion. Somatization, "somatic symptom disorder", and health anxiety are common terms used to describe the "slightly conversion disorder-y".
Such psychologizing diagnoses can be made even when physical health problems are objectively present in the patient, if clinicians suspect the patient is more bothered by those problems than a healthy-minded person "should" be.
Psychiatrist Allen Francis, among others, thinks that the "somatic symptom disorder" diagnosis should be scrapped; that diagnoses like "somatic symptom disorder" are too easily used to dismiss patients whose physical problems haven't been well-served by the current system, and to pathologize normal human unhappiness with physical discomfort and limitations.
I LOVE his first comment that we all need to hear different things at different times. This is so true and has lead to all sorts of pain in my life as I took on guilt and struggle that was not something I needed to take on. I see it in my school aged daughter (in a simple form) when she comes home worried the teacher is angry at her after a generic "you students need to act better" discussion. In the Other Feminisms context I suspect a lot of us need to remember it is ok to be dependant (and, in fact it is the way we are), however there are people who need to recognise the skills they have to be independent in some ways.
For the buttons, what about a simpler version of the same sentiment? For instance, "equality is not interchangeability" or even "equality ≠ interchangeability" instead of the full sentence?
Or even, "Equal, not interchangeable"?
This is the comment I signed in to make. The "premised on" construction is way too much syntax for a small sticker. Equality ≠ Interchangeability would be perfect.
I probably wouldn't use the ≠ symbol in this. First, because too many people don't know what it means; and second, because it's a math symbol, in which context equality actually is interchangeability.
Chiming in with some graphic design-y thoughts:
-on the yellow one, I recommend changing the font to something other than Impact. It’s a little overused. If you want something super easy to access but less overused you could try Helvetica or Gotham? Both of those are also used very often but idk what you have access to. Canva has a lot of good options as well! Try to go for something that isn’t known as a “display” font.
-on the purple/blue one, I recommend reducing the amount of space between the two lines of text (this is called “leading”), it’s a little too wide. I also recommend changing the colors to something less saturated; the current colors might not print well. Maybe a dustier or darker blue?
I like other people’s comments about shortening the phrases too. And I like the hand clip art. I love that you didn’t use AI!
I really appreciate these notes because I do not have a developed eye for this!
All the buttons are super wordy!
What about:
"(Human) Life is _Connected_",
"Equal not Identical", or
"For Woman as _Women_"
?
I think there are all sorts of ways to make these points that are punchy and don't read like the start of an academic essay,
"treat the patient’s pain as legitimate even if it didn’t have a clear-cut “answer” and formulate a treatment plan that would address the patient’s concerns while also being clear that they couldn’t promise a definitive solution. Doctors need to work a lot harder on developing these kinds of skills."
LOLOLOLOL understatement. Insurance billing incentivizes doctors to choose specificity over prudent hesitation. There is no billing code for "no definitive solution" that won't get you audited if you use it "too ofte" somehow. And even with nuanced training, doctors get the nuance beaten out of them by the medical system. Perverse incentives eventually result in doctors considering certain types of pain illegitimate, not because the pain isn't real but because the pain isn't provable or categorizable. Sigh
Just hear to say I love the non-pink options :) I have a "women/feminism" section of my bookshelf and I'm so annoyed at how pink it is. It isn't just your book. (I griped about this to my husband once and he pointed out that his copy of St. Ignatius's Spiritual Exercises, a 1970s printing, is the same color, ha)
I’m softening up a bit these days, but I had a strong and persistent I AM A GIRL WHO DOES NOT LIKE PINK phase as a child.
OK first I need to make a correction: here, not hear. With my background this is embarrassing for me, so, there's that.
Second, I'm really intrigued by this pink-as-female-coding thing. Of all stereotypes, this is the most superficial one.
If you have young children, see if your library has "The blue pickup" by Monica mikai and I can't remember the illustrator. It's a neat story about a girl who helps her granddad fix cars in Jamaica. I liked it enough to add to our home library. But it does have subtle "girl power" vibes which I keep thinking about. It's atypical but not subversive really for a girl to help fix cars. But there are hot pink flowers decorating every page, and in the end Granddad gives her a socket wrench set in a pink box. I don't really have any commentary here, it's just a thing I keep thinking about.
Yes, I think we've read that one!
But yeah, it's pretty silly--some of us flip out if a young boy chooses pink as his favorite color, too. So superficial! There are much more important things to worry about!
By Natasha Tripplett, Illustrated by Monica Mikai
https://www.harpercollins.com/products/the-blue-pickup-natasha-tripplett?variant=41057163903010
I like the women's equality not being interchangeable button.
As for the "untethered self" one, I wondered what was the real message? Two clasped hands, one appearing to be feminine, the other masculine. It seems to be celebrating the two as husband and wife clasped together and tethered.
It's a wonderful ideal, but what is it saying to those who haven't yet married, or who have lost their spouses through death? Are they being told that they are untethered and thus unreal?
I read the hands as more generic! I licensed stock art
Thanks for explaining, but even then, the message of being untethered could be linked with a different type of image if the goal is to encourage living in community with others. Perhaps a group of people together?
or very obviously different sized hands to depict a child and grownup?
I'm heading off to listen to the conversation now -- but meanwhile: What does "slightly conversion disorder-y problems" mean?
"What does 'slightly conversion disorder-y problems' mean?"
Since, in rare cases, purely psychological problems can produce dramatic physical effects (as in conversion disorder), it's therefore commonly speculated that, much more commonly, psychological problems outright cause, or at least needlessly worsen, patients' physical problems, especially the vaguer-seeming, tough-to-explain ones.
Especially when patients testify to a physical complaint that hasn't been verified by independent physical testing (sometimes because it can't affordably be verified this way; other times, it could be, but nobody has thought to try yet), clinicians may interpret the patient's testimony as evidence of a mainly, or at least significantly, psychological problem. (BD McClay describes how this works here: https://www.thedriftmag.com/the-bad-patient/ )
Maybe the patient is somatizing psychological distress, or has health anxiety blowing fairly minor ailments and discomforts all out of proportion. Somatization, "somatic symptom disorder", and health anxiety are common terms used to describe the "slightly conversion disorder-y".
Such psychologizing diagnoses can be made even when physical health problems are objectively present in the patient, if clinicians suspect the patient is more bothered by those problems than a healthy-minded person "should" be.
Psychiatrist Allen Francis, among others, thinks that the "somatic symptom disorder" diagnosis should be scrapped; that diagnoses like "somatic symptom disorder" are too easily used to dismiss patients whose physical problems haven't been well-served by the current system, and to pathologize normal human unhappiness with physical discomfort and limitations.
https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/dsm5-in-distress/201301/bad-news-dsm-5-refuses-to-correct-somatic-symptom-disorder
I LOVE his first comment that we all need to hear different things at different times. This is so true and has lead to all sorts of pain in my life as I took on guilt and struggle that was not something I needed to take on. I see it in my school aged daughter (in a simple form) when she comes home worried the teacher is angry at her after a generic "you students need to act better" discussion. In the Other Feminisms context I suspect a lot of us need to remember it is ok to be dependant (and, in fact it is the way we are), however there are people who need to recognise the skills they have to be independent in some ways.
i'd go further to suggest taking out text altogether for the Equal not Interchangeable buttons 🤭
Thanks for asking him my question!
Is the discussion available on Spotify or only through YouTube?