Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bernadette's avatar

I have had almost every kind of birth experience possible: hospital, medicated, homebirths with midwife with/without doula, one child I birthed entirely by myself, C-section, and VBAC. Giving birth is definitely one of the most vulnerable things a woman can do, and there are multiple reasons I can see why Jesus likens his Passion to a woman in travail. I personally didn't hit my birth stride until #3 because regardless of how much you witness birth...experiencing it is just something you can't entirely prepare for. Even when you are experienced there can be curveballs that must be fielded.

What I've kind of learned over the years is that regardless of what kind of birth you experience (natural, medicated, surgical, etc...) the kind of support you have AFTER giving birth is just as, or in some ways almost more, important than during birth itself. Obviously every woman is different so there's a lot of different experiences, but I recall reading about post partum care in Colonial times. Other women would come and take turns serving the family for 10 days. Every woman got 10 days even if they didn't need it, because 10 days would give more time to those who needed more time to recover without making them feel burdensome. I think that's the type of ritual that would be beneficial to revive among women as well. Good post partum support can heal even somewhat traumatic birth memories.

Expand full comment
Virginia's avatar

I've been thinking about the question ever since you asked it. Just had my first kid, and I'm not actually sure that having witnessed births would have made me any more prepared. I've never been present at someone else's birth, so the closest I've gotten were the birth videos from our childbirth-prep class at the hospital. Those mostly just made me dread the process more (and it wasn't a question of medicated/non-medicated -- the videos covered both and both had about the same effect on me). And once I was at the hospital for delivery, listening to the woman next door screaming in pain *definitely* did not help me relax or focus or anything else you're supposed to do in labor. So IDK -- maybe I'd be mentally tougher if I'd been at births when I was younger, before I had to seriously think about being in labor myself, but I'm not sure witnessing them as a young adult would be/would have been helpful.

Also re: what other commenters have mentioned about connections between labor and Jesus' passion -- that was a very comforting and helpful thought for me to hold onto in the weeks before delivery. I'd never thought of there being a connection until a couple months ago, but God showed it to me when I needed it.

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts