33 Comments
Mar 15, 2021Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant

We talked about this in my translation class! I had my students work on Rosalía de Castro's novella "Ruins," in which one of the main characters is an unmarried older woman. In order to figure out whether "solterona" (for instance) should be translated as "single woman" or "old maid," the students had to think about whether the narrative was judgmental and hostile toward this character and her status, or simply descriptive of it—and whether they wanted to reflect those attitudes, or subvert them. We learned a lot in this exercise. I wish I'd had the phrase "euphemism treadmill" in my arsenal back then!!

Expand full comment
author

This article, itself, is such a feat of translation!

Expand full comment
Mar 15, 2021Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant

Perhaps this doesn't count since it's fiction, but I've thought for years that I want to be Angela Lansbury's character in Murder She Wrote when I'm old. Not the detective work (I doubt I'd have the stomach for it!) but the independence, the kindness, the confidence, the willingness to trust others but also the ability to read others ... Anyway, that character embodies strong older femininity for me.

Expand full comment

And I just realized--this is not about a *name*, which was the actual question. Please delete if irrelevant!

But to answer the linguistic question: "old lady" was the way my siblings and I grew up talking about older women. I am fairly certain I wouldn't mind growing up to be an "old lady." Though I suspect that there are many women who would be more sensitive to the term ...

Expand full comment
author

It's a two part question—both about names and about role models! I'd hate to lose your response.

Expand full comment
Mar 15, 2021Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant

I personally aspire to become a crone.

One of my grandmothers lives nearby and I see her pretty regularly, but she's not what I would consider properly old, and all of my great-grandmothers (and my other grandmother) have died, so I'm a sort of trough in my contact with old women right now. Before my great-grandmothers died I would visit them in nursing homes, so I did see a lot of their co-residents. The nursing homes themselves were mostly depressing and I always thought the staff seemed weirdly condescending.

Expand full comment
author

I also figure myself for a crone. I love Granny Weatherwax from Terry Pratchett's Discworld series.

Expand full comment

My life partner was in an inpatient geriatric unit for a week, which was traumatic for both of us. From the start, it was a fight for dignity and respect as an individual wise elder with a fascinating and rich past. Right away they wanted her to sleep in a hospital gown "to make it easier to change her diapers." I said "She is not incontinent, sleeps in a t-shirt and panties, and that's the way it's going to stay." (many etc. could follow.) There are a few wonderful nursing homes, but most are understaffed by untrained aides who are forced to minimize all that those they care for would value most. As we drove away, my partner said "Already I feel myself coming back to life."

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Oh, how awful. I'm so sorry. Thank heavens that your sister-in-law did speak and sing to her in her native language. The staff's reaction is heartbreaking.

Expand full comment

there's 할머니 (grandma) in Korean and 아줌마 (middle aged woman). people address old ladies as 할머니 even if they're not related.

some of my aunts are older but I haven't seen them in person in a year because of the pandemic. Audrey Hepburn is someone I deeply admire, because she aged (even though she was only 63 when she died), but you got the sense that she was so happy and fulfilled, when we're usually told the opposite about growing older. she still had quite a lot to give and receive.

Expand full comment

“Euphemism treadmill” is a great phrase for a frustrating phenomenon. As long as the underlying attitude is negative simply changing the word is a bandaid approach. The new word will go the same way as its predecessors and people will continue to get bogged down in arguing over terminology which it seems to me is a distraction from the real work of loving people.

On the other hand the poet in me loves the challenge of trying to find a new and vigorous language that defies euphemisms and instead helps to show the person.

Expand full comment
author

I feel like it involves longer, more vivid phrases (like God's dandelion, above)

Expand full comment

Reading other comments here reminds me of a couple of things said about my life partner. When Marge was about 70, one of my friends at a big gathering said "Marge is juicy." I thought that was a high comment and something to which to aspire as I grew older. It might be useful to think of all the worse adjectives ascribed to older women in our culture, and then their antonyms, and come up with the terms for older women from there. If in China (?) the word for menopause is "second spring" then older women are getting ripe and lush -- some tart, some sweet, all individual, all gradually ripening and getting more delicious -- and juicy.

Expand full comment

I see that I said "high comment" and of course I meant "compliment." On the other hand, it was also a "high comment" in the sense of being astute.

Expand full comment

“ What names do you know for older women? Are there any you want to grow up to embody?”

Crone

Sage

Healer

The Elder

Oracle

And for me?? Masters Athlete

Expand full comment

I love "Masters Athlete" and "Sage!"

Expand full comment

"Yo, Wise Woman!" sounds pretty good to me. Wouldn't mind "Hey, you're the Matriarch. What do you advise us to do?" (Ha, apparently I missed the generation or culture where that's a realistic hope for me.) As an artist I've spent many years savoring the examples of older women artists. Louise Nevelson was am awesome model of a woman killing of the "Angel of the House" and apparently thriving. If I had to pick one older woman, it might be the British Columbian painter Emily Carr, who went beyond Nevelson to dedicate herself to her work -- enduring whatever it took to do so (freezing cold, extreme poverty, ridicule, social rejection) -- while also caring passionately for individual people and for the Indigenous tribes and their culture and well being. She tolerated no falseness or nonsense, and loved as tenderly as anyone might. Hard not to go on to add other women artists...and...my own mother, whose awesome self-discipline I'm appreciating more and more, some 25 years after her death.

Expand full comment

I -LOVE- "Hey, you're the Matriarch. What do you advise us to do?" I'm pretty sure that my family can use that for my beloved mother-in-law*... with a touch of affectionate humor. (It would be with humor not because she is female, but because she herself affirms to have never grown up! :) And indeed, she has not "grown up" in many of the dreadful status-seeking ways people often do... which would rather be to grow down†... ...and that is part of the secret of why she has attained so much of our respect!)

> 'Louise Nevelson was am awesome model of a woman killing of the "Angel of the House" and apparently thriving.'

I'm not sure what the reference is! (I aint too literary, here!) I did a search and, and found a poem... is that probably it?

* Actually, I notice that I much prefer "my hubbie's mom" or maybe "my kids' grandma" versus "mother-in-law" due to a historical spate of bitter jokes about "horrible mother-in-laws." But those other ways are so roundabout!! Oh... I once read a book by a woman who referred to her daughter-in-law as her "daughter-in-love." But I am afraid to try to start the trend of calling her "my mother-in-love"!! Maybe I can borrow the language of Paul: "[John]'s mother, who has been a mother to me as well." (modified from Romans 16:13)

† Is that from George MacDonald or C.S. Lewis? One of those people who successfully didn't "grow up," too terribly, I think!

Expand full comment

The "Angel in the House" is from Virginia Woolf's short book, "A Room of Her Own," which starts with imagining a Shakespeare's sister with the same talent and interests, but who "of course" took charge of the household, cooking, cleaning, and what is now called "emotional work" -- smoothing out relationships, tiptoing around the man's quirks, and generally being a helpful assistant. Woolf concludes in that book that not only does every woman need a room of her own -- to writing or whatever she wants to do that's NOT "her role in the family" -- every woman must also kill the Angel that whispers "isn't there the pantry to be organized better?" etc. every time the woman thinks she might have time for her own private work.

Expand full comment

Woolf concludes... that not only does every woman need a room of her own... ...every woman must also kill the Angel that whispers "𝓲𝓼𝓷'𝓽 𝓽𝓱𝓮𝓻𝓮 𝓪 𝔀𝓪𝔂 𝓯𝓸𝓻 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓹𝓪𝓷𝓽𝓻𝔂 𝓽𝓸 𝓫𝓮 𝓸𝓻𝓰𝓪𝓷𝓲𝔃𝓮𝓭 𝓫𝓮𝓽𝓽𝓮𝓻?" etc. every time the woman thinks she might have time for her own private work.

Heh, heh, heh. I'd like to say I'm an expert at that, but that's not quite what's going on.

Also, here's something I WROTE that very much relates to that: 'She walked downstairs and braced herself. It was about to begin. She'd barely cast her eyes on the floor when she saw the first one. The message popped up: "Legoes on floor." She quickly closed it out, then went on; the kitchen table was next.

"Dish," "food left out overnight," "dish," and "clutter" popped up four obedient textboxes. She turned her head away and ceased to see them...'

"Being distracted by tasks undone" as Augmented Reality... writing that was catharsis for me.

I think that in recent years, God has been good to me in helping me interweave my desire for "emotional work" / harmony between humans with my desire to write stuff, etc. (Honestly, I am a child of the internet, and the internet played a big role in the way that seemingly 'worked out'!)

Expand full comment

One name for older women that I've been reassessing lately is Crone. Becoming a Mother led me to realize that the Maiden-Mother-Crone trio of archetypes actually does point to real, distinctively felt stages of life for women. Female hormones and neurology change between these stages of life, in a way that they don't as much for males. Neurologists say that matrescence is as big of a transition for the brain as adolescence, and I believe them. I don't yet know how the shift to menopause feels, but no doubt I will find out.

Anabel Vizcarra, an "embodiment mentor and womb shaman," muses about the symbolism of menopause. To what degree this idea is historically accurate to some culture or other, I don't know, but it's certainly poetic:

"When a woman’s blood flow would stop coming it was said she no longer needed it, as she had accumulated the wisdom of the moon enough to embody it and invite it to stay. These wise women understood the importance of death and renewal at such a cellular level they no longer needed to be reminded every month."

I've read some quotes from Barbara G. Walker's book The Crone: Woman of Age, Wisdom, and Power, although I haven't read the whole thing. Two that stood out to me are:

"The Crone’s title was related to the word crown and she represented the power of the ancient tribal matriarch who made the moral and legal decisions for her subjects and descendants. It was the medieval metamorphosis of the wise woman into the witch that changed the word Crone from a compliment to an insult and established the stereotype of malevolent old womanhood that continues to haunt elder women today."

''Our culture's official rejection of the Crone figure was related to rejection of women, particularly elder women. The gray-haired high priestesses, once respected tribal matriarchs of pre-Christian Europe, were transformed by the newly dominant patriarchy into minions of the devil. Through the Middle Ages, this trend gathered momentum, finally developing a frenzy that legally murdered millions of elder women from the twelfth to the nineteenth centuries.''

Many pagan traditions honor older women with "croning" ceremonies. Here's one such example. This one is gender-neutral. Despite what I said about the uniqueness of female neurobiology, I can imagine that older men go through their own unique identity crises, so both genders could benefit from something like this:

https://atheopaganism.wordpress.com/2018/09/17/rites-of-passage-4-elderhood/

Expand full comment

Unfortunately, it appears that the etymological origin of 'crone' is not crown, but rather carrion.

Expand full comment

Ah, bummer. I should have quickly checked that on Etymonline myself. I just did, and you're right.

Expand full comment

I've looked at this page several times, and only now did I notice "eroding respect for the elderly." I'm not any more fond of the term "elderly" than I am of "seniors" or other euphemisms. Really, I'm just not fond of any labels, because they categorize -- whereas differences among human beings are always really gradations. "Older" at least leaves open the question "older than whom? Younger than whom?) "Biocognitive" researcher Mario Martinez suggests that our culture there's no advantage to telling anyone our age. Worth considering.

Expand full comment

One thing I loved about Martinez' anthropological approach is that in some Eastern culture (China? Not sure) -- menopause is called "The Second Spring."

Expand full comment

You've put your finger on one of the things that has really bothered me about the way people use language. I will remember this term "euphemism treadmill". I like to make a point of using a more original term even if it bothers people (for example, in England, the term "black" is not as offensive as I understand it is in the states) because I know that the "correct" terms will shift to satisfy some societal whim. Of course, this can hurt some people. Maybe this is a case of my turning naive theory into practice and mistaking the map for the territory, but it seems tragic to play into the dancing anxious game of catered language.

Expand full comment

Here in the U.S, sometimes white people bristle when Black is capitalized and white is not. For me, that usage began in the sixties and seventies, as part of the civil rights movement -- because it's what my Black colleagues wanted. What's truly offensive in the U.S. is the N word -- unless it's spoken by Blacks to each other. Which to me is sort of like one woman saying "Girl, why don't we..." while bristling if a man says "Why don't you girls..." (I still prefer "woman" and don't get me started on "lady" and "ladies" after years of being referred to as "a lady blacksmith."

Expand full comment

funnily enough. I have a friend who's a blacksmith. Also, if you don't like "lady blacksmith", what do you like? It strikes me as sounding better than "girl blacksmith" or "female blacksmith". I confess to often resorting to the term "lady" in similar contexts.

Expand full comment

Just "blacksmith" or "smith." Because...few male smiths are described as "gentleman blacksmiths" or "boy blacksmiths" or "male blacksmiths" -- unless there's some contrast or comparison that's really necessary for an article or discussion.

Expand full comment

I've always liked the Spanish word viejita which is the diminutive of vieja, old woman. It sounds affectionate to me, but I'm not a native speaker so I could be mistaken about this. However, my parents used the word natively, and I never got the impression that it was negative or condescending. Same with abuelita, another diminutive which means, sweet, cute, or little grandmother. I associate viejita with those one or two little old ladies at church whose quavering voices stand out when the congregation is singing hymns in Spanish.

Expand full comment
author

I'm very envious of the tender diminutives of languages like Spanish or Russian.

Expand full comment

Some of my friends bristle when a waitress or clerk calls them "darling" or "dear" or something. I think it's just southern and I don't mind it. Diminutives can get a bit dangerous in closer relationships that you want to be "power with" not "power over." I learned from examples in Sonia Johnson's book, "Wildfires," how they can be so subtly condescending that they're impossible to protest, yet establish a power-over relationship. (That said, I still like the phrase from high school French, though, "ma petite chou" (my little cabbage).

Expand full comment
deletedMar 15, 2021Liked by Leah Libresco Sargeant
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I wish English had the custom of addressing the elderly as "grandmother" and "grandfather" (I believe the same Ivan has discussed this on Twitter), which could theoretically also be adopted for referring to the elderly. But maybe that would just end up sounding dismissive, like "Gramps."

Expand full comment